Challenge 115, your thoughts

[pensnest]

Right, so the voting is done on Challenge #115, and I'll be posting results this evening, but while I do the banners, how about your thoughts on this challenge.

Did you enjoy having to find your own images? Was it a theme that you found appealing?

When it came to voting, is it harder to vote where the icons are not all derived from the same images so that you're not comparing directly? Do your personal voting criteria change, with this kind of variety available?

Other thoughts?

Comments

[stripped]

I think the big thing it changed for voting was that without them tending to be similar, there isn't one that just jumps out. But I liked it, too, both as an artist and as a voter, because it allowed for creativity and it was really interesting seeing how folks worked on the theme.